“ Excellent food and service. Good bar drinks. Salad bar was outstanding. NE Clam Chowder was a bit watery, but everything else was spot on. The BBQ ribs were orgasmic ! Can't wait to visit again next time I'm in Naples, from which it's a short drive to get there, and well worth it ! ”

“ Excellent dinner. Colleen was our server, and she was professional, attentive, and personable. Salad bar amazing. Main dishes great. Looks like a popular spot. This was our second time there. Forgot to take pictures last time. It’s a bit of a drive from 41 and Collier, but it’s worth it. ”

“ First time to the new location of The Pewter Mug. Miss the old location atmosphere but big improvement to the space of the new location. The food her is always Amazing. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Their prime rib melts in your mouth and is well worth the price. And of course their salad bar is amazing! Staff is great there and food is delivered quickly. Dont miss out on one of the best restaurants in southwest FL! ”

“ Great local gem with excellent food. Plenty of parking in a large lot out front. Be prepared for a wait even with a reservation. We arrived at 7:00 for 7:15 reservation and still waited 30 minutes. That's okay because there's a nice bar with friendly bartenders. Good beer selection. Had a great server who was very attentive. Salad bar is awesome. Great baked salad and soup bar but be careful not to fill up. I strongly recommend the blackened chicken Alfredo. Absolutely delicious. Food slow coming out. Busy night so I understand but too slow. Hot and delicious once it arrived. Had to skip dessert but what I saw walking by looked great. We'll be back. ”

“ Great Food! Fantastic Salad Bar We always go here when we travel in the Naples area Don’t miss it ”

“ We made reservation and were seated immediately. We went for the early dinner special. The salad / soup bar was unbelievable! The items were fresh the chives were ample. Our server was Kylie and she was amazing! Great service and attentive. It was the first time we have been there and most definitely not the last time. % recommend. ”

“ The Pewter Mug; I forgot to get our servers name. He was a tall blonde man. He was very good. Super great with explanations, and since it was our first visit, he explained how everything works at the pewter mug. Which was very helpful. Our orders were perfect. Everything came as requested, and he visited often to fill drinks or to check in. We brought our 1.5 year old baby girl, and the restaurant was buzzing with guests, so she didn't disturb anyone. The highchair they supplied was clean & modern. A very great experience. The menu is varied and has many options for everyone. They have a nice salad bar, soup bar, and cheese and bread roll bar. They also have specials. On the night we visited, it was Roast Triple Tail over pasta. Loaded baked potato soup and onion soup. They're known for their premiere Prime Rib Dinners. My wife ordered the 10oz Prime Rib. Well done, baked sweet potato with brown sugar and butter. I had their French Dip, of which came with provolone cheese, and I ordered their loaded baked potato. All entrees come with their salad bar of which had a lot of choice. I appreciated their old school offerings and the more modern salad bar options. What I loved was the Three Bean Salad, The Beets, The Cottage Cheese, Sweet Peas Salad, and Pasta Salad. I never get to have three bean salads, and that was cool. They have some dessert options, but we were thoroughly stuffed and could not indulge. It's all around great place. One that we will need to try over and over again. It's not fine dining but just a good family style restaurant with good food, good portions, good variety, high-quality Prime Rib, and a nice salad bar. They have a variety of starters, seafood entrees, and entrees from the land. Lots of choices. Great for everyone. Great service. Family atmosphere. Lots of conversations and buzzing. I believe they also had a separate bar area and another dining room. So two dining rooms and a bar dining area with tvs playing at the bar with football on my visit. It wasn't bar focused, though. I kind of liked that it was spread out a bit and separated. You'll need to visit yourself to see. I believe they've been in business for over 70 years in their old location. This was for their new building, which is a larger space with great parking. I think I've just about covered everything. Will edit my review if things change in the future. Definitely give them a try. Look out for that tall blonde man who provided my family with expert old school service. It is very much appreciated. Thank you. (I am a Local Naples Chef: My review was unsolicited, honest, my opinion only, I am in no way affiliated with The Pewter Mug, I am just a local chef, foodie & food critic) ”

“ Good food (4.5)and salad/soup bar is included in the entree price. Lively atmosphere on the bar dining side and a little quieter on the other dining side. Service was pretty good. Food was a bit bland could definitely use a little seasoning on my ribeye and my wife’s beef stroganoff. ”